[roads] all renderers fail to render cycleway:X=track #2195
Comments
Author: Ldp Doing :left and :right in the renderers is pretty difficult or almost impossible, although work is being done to add support in mapnik. Until then, it's impossible to proceed with this ticket. |
Author: ChrisB Out of curiosity, why so difficult? If it is difficult/impossible, then the notation itself should be deprecated and mappers told to use separate ways instead. |
Author: Ldp In a sense, mappers are already being told to do just that, by the statements by some that cycleway=track is deprecated. But I digress, that's just politics. :) The technical difficulty is that up to now, neither of the two most-used rendering engines (mapnik and osmarender) could draw a line parallel to a way. As I said, work is being done on the mapnik render software right now, to incorporate just such a functionality. It still needs to be fleshed out and tested, but it opens up interesting possibilities in the future. |
Author: ChrisB This is possibly the same problem: [http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=55.92922&lon=-3.20455&zoom=17&layers=B000FTF here] is Canaan Lane, for the sections that are oneway there is a counterflow cycle lane, marked with cycleway=opposite_lane. This doesn't get rendered with Mapnik or Osmarender. |
Author: ZMWandelaar We are now 17 months later now. Mapnik2 is comming up. Is the situation on the renderer possibilities changed? |
Author: Ldp No, it hasn't changed. |
Author: dieterdreist Replying to [comment:3 ChrisB]:
: it is deprecated and against the common rule: if the ways are separated, draw a distinct way. |
Author: deif Now that Carto CSS is used to draw the default Mapnik style has the situation changed? |
Author: math1985 I think this is too specific for a generic purpose map. Cyclists can use opencyclemap. I will therefore close this issue as wontfix. |
Reporter: ChrisB
[Submitted to the original trac issue database at 12.00pm, Tuesday, 18th August 2009]
[http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=56.04021&lon=-3.35912&zoom=16&layers=B000FTF Here] we have a road with a segregated cycleway running alongside it. The way is classified using the [http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:cycleway cycleway:left=track notation]
Osmarender, Mapnik and the Cyclemap all fail to render the cycleway alongside the road.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: