Opened 8 years ago

Closed 7 years ago

#3856 closed defect (invalid)

Addresses in "Bad Ragaz" belong to the wrong district

Reported by: tubeli Owned by: geocoding@…
Priority: minor Milestone:
Component: nominatim Version:
Keywords: Cc:

Description

By typing "Bad Ragaz" into the search field in Mapquest and selecting for example Gas stations or restaurants, they show up to belong to "Distretto di Riviera" (see below), which is wrong, this place is in the southern part of Switzerland, wheras Bad Ragaz is in the Canton of St. Gallen. The solution to the problem is to remove both the "Distretto di Lugano" and the "Distretto di Riviera". I don't know where exactly the error comes from but at least with all addresses I checked in Bad Ragaz, it happened. Also "Distretto di Moesa" pops up for some (e.g. the Restaurant Trocadero)

Here follows the "details" for the query in Nominatim:

Bad Ragaz
Name:
Bad Ragaz (name)
Type: place:town
Admin Level: 15
Rank: Village / Hamlet
Coverage: Point
OSM: node 240123028
Extra Tags:
4929 (population)
Address
Bad Ragaz (Type: place:town, node 240123028, 15, , Polygon, 0 GOTO)
Distretto di Riviera (Type: place:county, node 240083106, 15, , Polygon, 0.850360887330312 GOTO)
Distretto di Lugano (Type: place:county, node 412916801, 15, , Polygon, 1.11782248377333 GOTO)
St. Gallen (Type: boundary:administrative, relation 365663, 4, , Polygon, 0.323308078855489 GOTO)
Glarus (Type: place:state, node 313872884, 15, , Polygon, 0.393497179204133 GOTO)
St. Gallen (Type: place:state, node 313873770, 15, , Point, 0.224186212174298 GOTO)
Appenzell Ausserrhoden (Type: place:state, node 240086063, 15, , Polygon, 0.415423805577147 GOTO)
St. Gallen (Type: place:state, node 313873770, 15, , Polygon, 0.224186212174298 GOTO)
Appenzell Innerrhoden (Type: place:state, node 240071290, 15, , Polygon, 0.315319668402463 GOTO)
Graubünden - Grigioni - Grischun (Type: place:state, node 240035066, 15, , Polygon, 0.322709263775199 GOTO)
Switzerland (Type: boundary:administrative, relation 51701, 2, , Polygon, 1.28693454492985 GOTO)
Switzerland (Type: boundary:administrative, relation 51701, 2, , Polygon, 1.28693488607387 GOTO)
Switzerland (Type: boundary:administrative, relation 51701, 2, , Polygon, 1.28693664431536 GOTO)
Switzerland (Type: boundary:administrative, relation 51701, 2, , Point, 1.28693454492985 GOTO)
Switzerland (Type: boundary:administrative, relation 51701, 2, , Polygon, 1.28693730292412 GOTO)
ch (Type: place:country_code, , , Polygon, 0 GOTO)
Europe (Type: place:continent, node 25871341, 15, , Point, 4.02841677258847 GOTO)

Change History (2)

comment:1 Changed 7 years ago by Tom Hughes

Owner: changed from openstreetmap@… to geocoding@…

comment:2 Changed 7 years ago by Sarah Hoffmann

Resolution: invalid
Status: newclosed

Data issue. Was resolved with the boundary import in Switzerland.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.